Wednesday, January 14, 2015

Legionnaire's Disease Unraveled

Legionnaire’s Disease is a bacterial infection of the lungs brought on by a type of bacteria commonly found in water supplies.  This bacterial type was first isolated when a number of attendees to an American Legion convention came down with a mysterious respiratory illness.  A number of those who contracted this disease did not recover.  This was the beginning of the fearsome reputation of Legionaire’s Disease.  The newly discovered bacterium was named “Legionella.”

It is estimated that there are thousands of occurrences of this disease every year.  Very frequently it is diagnosed simply as pneumonia. The high mortality of the first recognized encounter with the disease was evidently due to the general health of the patients.  They were all older men who smoked and drank and therefore had low resistance to infection.  Nevertheless, Legionnaire’s Disease is even now rarely diagnosed.  There are estimates that 30 to 40% of pneumonia cases where the cause is unknown may be due to Legionella exposure.  As many as 25,000 deaths per year that are attributed generally to pneumonia may actually be Legionnaire’s disease. 

Symptoms of Legionnaire’s Disease include fever, hacking cough, abdominal pains, diarrhea, headaches, body aches, fatigue, and weight loss.  All symptoms may not be present in all patients, but these are the symptoms to look for.

Pontiac Fever is another disease that is caused by Legionella.  This disease is characterized by flu-like symptoms.  People who suffer from this disease usually get well on their own in a few days.  Why two different diseases result from the same bacterium is an unanswered question.  Pontiac Fever was actually isolated prior to Legionaire’s  Disease.  It was named for the city where it was first encountered.  Only after Legionella was isolated as the bacteria causing Legionaire’s Disease that it was discovered the two shared the same bacterial type as the source of infection.

There are no indications that either disease is spread from person to person.  Evidence strongly suggests that these diseases are contracted in a manner similar to the way the Legionnaires became ill, by inhaling water droplets from Legionella contaminated water sources.  Legionella can proliferate in water temperatures between approximately 65 and 130 degrees Fahrenheit. 

Considering Legionella-friendly water temperatures, the suggested setting for water heaters at between 110 and 120 degrees for energy conservation should be reconsidered.  At these temperatures hot water supplies are at an ideal temperature for Legionella to grow and prosper.  So what is resulting in energy savings could be endangering the health of thousands.  At the suggested temperature settings a person would be particularly susceptible to Legionella exposure in a shower or whirlpool bath. 
Setting hot water temperatures at above 130 degrees would be prudent to discourage the growth of Legionella in these reservoirs.  Keep in mind if you decide to increase the temperature of your water heater to decrease the growth of Legionella take precautions not to scald yourself or others because of the new higher water temperature.   The higher water temperature is especially important if you have an electric water heater.  Studies show that the growth of Legionella is considerably more likely in electric water heaters than in gas-fired ones.  Sediment that collects in the bottom of water heaters can become a near ideal environment for Legionella.  The heating elements of gas-fired water heaters are located at the bottom of the tank where this sediment is often heated to a temperature too high for Legionella to survive or to proliferate.  Electric water heaters often have their heating elements along the side of the tank; therefore they are less likely to heat the sediment at the bottom of the tank high enough to discourage the growth of Legionella.   Changing your electric water heater for a gas-fired one would prudent if affordable. 

In addition to sediment and stagnant water areas, Legionella also in biofilm.  Biofilms are composed of microorganisms that become attached to surfaces of pipes, rubber washers/gaskets and especially in stagnant areas of water systems.  Change rubber washers and gaskets frequently, especially in showers and bathtubs.  This will help to reduce the build-up of biofilm.

If your office building, or an adjacent office building has a cooling tower satisfy yourself that it is being properly maintained.  Question your safety officer or the maintenance personnel responsible for maintaining the system.  Questions should include how often the cooling tower is flushed and cleaned; what standards are used for maintaining biocide levels and how often are they checked.  If you are satisfied with leaving these questions to government regulators, that is fine.  Just recognize that often governments are so busy enforcing the many inane laws and regulations, they are not paying enough attention to practicing their primary responsibility – the protection of their citizens.  Also ensure that potable water systems are properly maintained by periodic checks for Legionella.  Ensure any water heaters in the building are not set to energy conservation levels but at a temperature that will not be conducive to enhancement of Legionella growth.  In the end, we are all responsible for our own health and safety plus that of our families. 

It is often said that a little knowledge is a dangerous thing.  But sometimes all it takes is a little knowledge to enable us to take necessary survival steps and it is a lack of knowledge that might be dangerous or even lethal.


  1. Nice information, keep it up!

    Paket Peninggi Badan, Pelangsing, Penggemuk, dan Pencerah Kulit

  2. We have a room disinfection system that kills legionnaires and many other pathogens very effectively:

    1. I would be interested in hearing about it.

  3. This comment has been removed by the author.